The NFL’s Antitrust Lawsuit and OTA Practice Controversy: A Perfect Storm

The National Football League (NFL) is facing a class-action lawsuit filed by ‘Sunday Ticket’ subscribers, claiming the league broke antitrust laws. This comes at a time when the Detroit Lions are forfeiting a practice due to violating player work rules regarding on-field physical contact. The lawsuit, filed in 2015, has withstood numerous challenges and is expected to begin this week.

Image: NFL logo

The lawsuit alleges that the NFL broke antitrust laws when it allowed DirecTV to exclusively sell the ‘Sunday Ticket’ package of out-of-market Sunday afternoon games airing on CBS and Fox at what it says was an inflated price and restricted competition. The NFL will contend that ‘Sunday Ticket’ is an add-on package for the league’s most-devoted and out-of-town fans, along with stating that all games for local teams are available on broadcast networks.

A courtroom where the lawsuit will be heard

NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell and Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones, a longtime member of the league’s broadcast committee, are expected to testify in the case that could last up to three weeks. The hearing could bring to light how much YouTube is paying the NFL for ‘Sunday Ticket’ and if it is making money. There also could be documents filed and not redacted that would show how much networks spend to produce an NFL game.

NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell

Meanwhile, the Detroit Lions are facing consequences for violating player work rules regarding on-field physical contact during Organized Team Activities (OTAs). The team announced Friday evening that they were notified by the NFL and NFLPA that their OTA practices held the week of May 27 violated player work rules pertaining to on-field physical contact pursuant to the Collective Bargaining Agreement. As a result, the team’s OTA practice scheduled for Monday, June 10 has been forfeited.

Detroit Lions logo

The Lions take very seriously the rules set forth within the NFL’s Offseason Program and have worked to conduct their practices accordingly. They will continue to be vigilant with their practices moving forward.

A football field where OTAs are held

This is one of the rare times the NFL has had a high-profile case go to court where league financial matters would become public without settling. In 2021, it settled with St. Louis, St. Louis County and the St. Louis Regional Convention and Sports Complex Authority for $790 million over the relocation of the Rams to Los Angeles.

Court documents that may be revealed during the lawsuit

The NFL’s antitrust lawsuit and the Lions’ OTA practice controversy are two separate issues that have brought attention to the league’s rules and financial dealings. As the lawsuit unfolds, it will be interesting to see how the NFL responds to the allegations and what implications this may have on the league’s future.

NFL shield